# Morses Club PLC Q&A with Hardman & Co Analyst Mark Thomas (LON:MCL)

- Link: https://www.directorstalkinterviews.com/morse-club-plc-qa-hardman-co-analyst-mark-thomas-lonmcl/412723780
- Published: 2017-02-14T07:30:54+00:00
- Author: Amilia Stone

**Hardman & Co** Analyst Mark Thomas caught up with DirectorsTalk for an exclusive
interview to discuss **[Morses Club](https://www.directorstalkinterviews.com/company/morses-club-plc/mcl.l)
PLC** ([LON:MCL](https://www.directorstalkinterviews.com/company/morses-club-plc/mcl.l))

 

**Q1: Now Mark, Morses Club, a home collect credit company, what is so attractive
about this market that it’s in?**

**A1**: Well, we believe the home credit collect market offers excellent risk reward
opportunities for investors, the key issues are two-fold; there’s real sustainable
demand for the product and secondly there are barriers which prevent large mainstream
lenders attacking it.

Taking the demand first, customers who were unable to access mainstream lending 
have a convenient product at a fair price which is well below most of the alternative
available financing source, they like it, with independent surveys showing 95-97%
are either satisfied or very satisfied with the product. The agent relationship 
is key to this service and these satisfaction levels, it embeds Morses Club PLC 
in the community and it is essential to the effective management of credit, it cannot
be replicated by the computer systems used by mainstream companies. Statistical 
models tell you the ability of the customer to repay but it’s an experienced agent
that tells you whether they’re willing to do so, the borrowers are on variable incomes,
do several jobs, very tight budgets and it’s the agents that knows whether the £
5 or £10 a week they have left over each week will be used to repay debt. The agent
will also know the local factory is doing well or if it’s laying off staff and a
model thousands of miles away simply cannot do that, the agent is a key barrier 
to entry which means that the good returns which are currently being earned are 
sustainable ones.

 

**Q2: Given the high interest rates, won’t the regulator intervene sooner rather
than later and impose price caps?**

**A2**: The price may appear high, certainly relative to mainstream products, but
what you have to bear in mind is it’s appropriate to the high costs of delivering
a face-to-face service model and also the credit experience of this business where,
roughly speaking, 25% of revenue would be lost in terms of credit losses. Now, arrears
are managed very carefully with controlled forbearance, they’re not done by imposing
penalties, the customer’s ability and willingness to repay are fundamental to the
lending decision, the agent can know the customer a zillion times better than any
computer-driven model can and you cannot ignore the fact that the customer likes
the product.

At the end of the day, all of these features are recognised by the regulator, it’s
a reasonable price, the customers like it and it’s a customer that’s very well-known.
All the previous reviews of home collect credit have not resulted in any material
business change or any material adverse profit impact, there have been small operational
changes but they’re relatively minor. Morse Club PLC’s business is not a payday 
lender, its interest rates are about half the cap the FCA imposed on that business,
it’s not exposed to any further remedies to payday lending market, the November 
2016 FCA review is much more targeted at the rent-to-buy market where customer affordability
is very poor, the customers are barely known, you’re not embedded in the community.
In some ways, home collectors are more of a solution than a problem.

 

**Q3: But isn’t the business terribly high-risk, won’t a recession or the later 
stages of austerity hitting benefits mean credit losses will rocket?**

**A3**: Taking on the recession point first, when you get economic distress the 
number of customers who drop out of prime status goes up, massively increasing the
potential pool of customers that Morse Club can address. Secondly, Morses Club can
reprice, it’s much easier to add 20% to a loan with an APR of 200/300/400% than 
it is to actually add 1% to a mortgage where you might be charging 3-4%, funding
costs will rise but the bottom line is incredibly resilient because you’ve got more
customers and you can reprice, if you look at Provident Financial’s profits, they
actually rose from 207-2009 and how many lenders can actually say that.

Looking at austerity you have to recognise the vast majority of customers’ income
actually comes from jobs, not benefits, the jobs may not be 9-5, the income maybe
variable but the business is not about lending to people and taking their benefits.

 

**Q4: Is home collect going to show any growth, do you think?**

**A4**: The overall market volume has been broadly stable and low single digit growth
is what we expect to continue, Morses Club can grow much faster than that though.
Firstly, it’s using technology to improve its efficiency, it delivered a 7% productivity
improvement in the first half, it’s improved revenue, its tightly controlled credit
and looking outside its own business, Morses Club has been expanding by attracting
experienced agents from competitors, acquiring books of customers where mature owners
with small businesses simply can’t work in the current regulatory world. It’s used
technology to attract new customers via things like the web, it’s introducing new
products in related areas where it has a competitive advantage, it already has the
contact centre, the credit tools, the customer web flow, product sweeps to address
online lending and the potential there is huge. The nature of the company is very
conservative, we expect slow considered growth from these new product areas but 
Morses Club can grow much faster than the market.

 

**Q5: Now, looking at your notes, they spend a lot of time on accounting, why is
that?**

**A5**: It’s unfortunate that we need to get a bit nerdy here but home collect as
a market, so this is all the players in home collect, it’s a very small part of 
the overall lending market and accounting rules that are reasonable for the mainstream
actually create major distortions. The biggest single one arises on discounting 
cash flows using the customer interest rate which we believe massively understates
the value of a company like Morses Club PLC.

In our note, we give an example of a loan of £100, now quite sensibly that is initially
valued at £100, it’s what you would expect, where the customer misses two payments
and a lot of home collect customers do that but they still fully repay, the accounting
rules say you must value the loan on expected cash flows discounted to a present
value using the customer interest rate. Now, with modest discount rates that’s perfectly
reasonable but the interest rate in home collect reflect the higher service cost
and the high credit experience in that market, using the interest rate driven by
those factors means that that discounting factor is way too high, a £100 loan would
actually get discounted to £46.80 even though the expected losses would be just 
£16.25. Now, valuing the loan at £46.80 reduce equity, it could actually run into
tens of millions of pounds compared to the value of the company’s equity, by way
of illustration, if I discounted the same cash flow at 25% a reasonable return on
equity the NPV would actually go up, not down.

Share on:
