# Mercantile Investment Trust plc NAV return for the year was +5.4%, outperforming benchmark

- Link: https://www.directorstalkinterviews.com/mercantile-investment-trust-plc-nav-return-for-the-year-was-5.4-outperforming-benchmark/4121151277
- Published: 2024-04-12T07:34:25+01:00
- Author: Amilia Stone

Mercantile Investment Trust plc (LON:MRC) has announced its annual financial results
for the period ended 31st January 2024.

**Highlights**

·    The Company’s net asset total return, based on debt at par value, was +4.5%;
with the debt at fair, the return for the year was +5.4%; and the total return to
shareholders was +6.1%. The Company outperformed its benchmark, which returned +
1.8%.

·    In the ten years ended 31st January 2024, the Company has generated an average
annualised return of +6.1% per annum on a net asset total return par value basis,
and +6.4% in share price terms, comfortably ahead of the benchmark’s average annual
return of +4.5%.

·    The Board has declared a fourth quarterly interim dividend of 3.30p per share.
This brings the total dividend for the year to 7.65p per share, an increase of 7.0%
over last year. On an annualised basis the dividend has grown by 6.7% per annum 
over the last ten years.

·    The Company’s discount fluctuated between 9.7% and 16.7% during the period 
under review, but ended the year at 12.6%, in-line with where it began a year ago.

> **Angus Gordon Lennox, Chairman, commented:**
> “Despite [a] generally unsupportive environment, most of the Company’s portfolio
> holdings continued to do well at an operational level, and I am pleased to report
> a positive performance from the Company over the year under review, on both an
> absolute and relative basis.
> Existing portfolio holdings have been performing well despite the challenging 
> conditions of the past year and should do even better as and when the economy 
> strengthens. In addition, the current very attractive valuations mean new investment
> opportunities among mid and smaller cap stocks are numerous, and the Portfolio
> Managers’ track record attests to their ability to identify and capitalise on 
> the most compelling of these opportunities.”

> **Guy Anderson and Anthony Lynch, Portfolio Managers, commented:**
> “This has been a rather testing year for the UK market, with the direction of 
> travel being driven to a major extent by the path of inflation, the actions of
> the Bank of England, and the impact of these upon expectations of future economic
> growth.
> Performance this year was aided by a strong outturn from several of our longer-
> standing investments, led by our substantial holdings in the investment banking
> and brokerage services sector.
> Portfolio turnover has remained somewhat lower than long-term averages, reflecting
> what we believe to be a resiliently positioned portfolio and our clear focus on
> the long-term prospects of holdings.
> We are excited by the investment opportunities that [a] combination of low valuations,
> improving economic indicators, and strong performing portfolio companies yields.
> This backdrop explains our elevated level of gearing, which at the date of this
> report is approximately 15%. This is the highest level of gearing that we have
> applied in over a decade, which hopefully demonstrates most clearly our assessment
> of the opportunity before us.”

**CHAIRMAN’S STATEMENT**

**Market Background**

UK equity markets spent most of the past year worrying about stubbornly high inflation,
the Bank of England’s determination to restrain inflation pressures by tightening
the monetary policy reins, and the risk this posed to economic activity. However,
market sentiment improved somewhat towards the end of the year as inflation began
to slow and investors started to foresee interest rate cuts during 2024. Nonetheless,
there remains a degree of negativity priced into the market at current levels. A
lack of clarity about the path of interest rates and economic outlook weighed more
heavily on medium and smaller cap companies than on larger cap stocks, given that
smaller businesses are usually more vulnerable to rising interest rates and economic
downturns. As a result, mid and small cap stocks are trading at historically wide
discounts to larger caps, giving rise to opportunities for your Company.

**Performance**

Despite this generally unsupportive environment, most of the Company’s portfolio
holdings continued to do well at an operational level, and I am pleased to report
a positive performance from the Company over the year under review, on both an absolute
and relative basis. For the financial year ended 31st January 2024 (FY24), the Company’s
net asset total return, based on debt at par value, was +4.5%; with the debt at 
fair, the return for the year was +5.4%; and the total return to shareholders was
+6.1%. The Company showed good outperformance against its benchmark, which returned
+1.8%.

The Company’s average annualised return over ten years ended 31st January 2024 was
+6.1% per annum on a net asset total return par value basis, and +6.4% in share 
price terms, comfortably ahead of the benchmark’s average annual return of +4.5%.
This long-term track record of high absolute returns and outperformance of the broader
small and medium cap market attests to your Portfolio Managers’ skill at identifying
this sector’s future market leaders and outperformers.

The Portfolio Managers’ Report below discusses recent performance and portfolio 
changes in more detail, as well as considering their outlook for the coming year.

**Returns and Dividends**

The Company aims to provide shareholders with long term dividend growth at least
in line with the rate of inflation over a five-to-ten-year period, as detailed in
the table below. The Company has paid three interim dividends of 1.45p per ordinary
share in respect of the year to 31st January 2024 and the Board has declared a fourth
quarterly interim dividend of 3.30p per share. This brings the total dividend for
the year to 7.65p per share, an increase of 7.0% over last year.

| ** ** | **CPI** | **Mercantile Dividend Growth** | 
| ** ** | **(% per annum)** | **(% per annum)** | 
| Three Years | 6.0% | 4.5% | 
| Five Years | 4.1% | 4.0% | 
| Ten Years | 2.8% | 6.7% |

Source: Office of National Statistics/J.P. Morgan.

In deciding the Company’s dividend payments during normal market conditions, the
Board looks to pay dividends that are at least covered by current year earnings,
while also allowing the Company to build revenue reserves. However, it is a great
advantage of the investment trust structure that the Company has the option to partially
fund dividend payments from revenue reserves, when necessary, to bolster the dividend
during challenging times. The Company utilised this option in the three financial
years FY20, FY21 and FY22. Then, having weathered these ‘COVID years’, total dividends
for FY23 were fully covered by earnings, and I am pleased to report this remains
the case again in FY24. Revenues per share over the past year increased by 25.3%,
to 9.01p, from 7.19p in the previous year. This means that the Company has been 
able to increase the FY24 total dividend by a healthy margin, while also adding 
a meaningful amount to its reserves, to support dividends in any future lean years.
After payment of the fourth interim dividend, the Company will have revenue reserves
of more than 6.5p per share (2023: 4.9p).

**Discount**

Although it fluctuated between 9.7% and 16.7% during the period under review, the
Company’s discount of 12.6% at year end was largely the same as where it began a
year ago. Your Directors recognise that it is in the interests of shareholders that
the Company’s share price does not differ excessively from the underlying NAV under
normal market conditions. With market conditions continuing to be challenging, in
an effort to equalise supply and demand and support the share price, during FY24
the Board utilised the Company’s authority to buy back shares, repurchasing a total
of 8,024,097 shares, at a cost of £16.5 million. These shares were purchased at 
an average discount to NAV of 12.7%, producing a modest accretion to the NAV for
continuing shareholders.

The Board closely monitors the discount and market conditions and will continue 
to undertake share buybacks when it deems such action to be appropriate. My fellow
directors and I therefore recommend that shareholders approve the renewal of the
authority to repurchase up to 14.99% of the Company’s shares at the forthcoming 
Annual General Meeting, with repurchased shares to be cancelled or held in Treasury.
The Board is again seeking shareholder approval to issue shares at a premium to 
NAV and to disapply pre-emption rights on any such issues. As with buying shares
at a discount, issuing new shares at a premium to NAV enhances returns to existing
shareholders and improves liquidity.

**Gearing**

It is the Board’s intention that the Company continues to operate within the range
of 10% net cash to 20% geared, under normal market conditions. The Company ended
the year with gearing of 13.4%, up from 9.5% at the same time last year. This is
the highest level of gearing in over ten years, reflecting the Portfolio Managers’
positive outlook as discussed in their report.

Having gone into the downturn modestly geared – positioning which detracted from
performance – the Board is especially keen to ensure that the level of gearing enhances
the Company’s exposure to a market upturn.

The Company’s balance sheet and levels of gearing are regularly discussed by the
Board and the Portfolio Managers. Gearing is achieved via the use of long-dated,
fixed-rate financing, from several sources, consistent with the Board’s aim to ensure
diversification of the source, tenure and cost of leverage available to the Company.
The Company has in place a £3.85 million perpetual debenture and a £175 million 
debenture repayable on 25th February 2030, together with £150 million of long-term
debt raised in September 2021 via the issuance of three fixed rate, senior unsecured,
privately placed notes (the ‘Notes’). These Notes mature between 2041 and 2061 and
were secured at a blended rate of 1.94%, at a time when interest rates were near
their lows.

**Marketing, Promotion and Shareholder Interaction**

The Company continues to raise its profile with investors and potential investors,
via targeted media and promotional campaigns, and ongoing interaction with national
and investment industry journalists. It is the Board’s view that enhancing the Company’s
profile will benefit all shareholders, by creating sustained demand for its shares,
particularly from retail investors, where demand has grown steadily in recent years.
We seek to undertake this promotional activity in the most cost-effective manner.

To further promote the Company to the broader investment community, the Manager 
follows an established marketing and investor relations programme targeting wealth
managers, institutions and private client stockbrokers via video conferences, podcasts
and in-person meetings.

The Board and the Investment Managers also maintain a dialogue with the Company’s
shareholders via regular email updates, which deliver news and views, and discuss
the latest performance. If you have not already signed up to receive these communications
and you wish to do so, you can opt in via **www.Mercantile-Registration.co.uk** 
or by scanning the QR code in Company’s Annual Report & Financial Statements for
the Year Ended 31st January 2024 (‘2024 Annual Report’).

It is the Board’s hope that these initiatives will give many more of the Company’s
investors and potential investors the opportunity to interact with the Board and
Portfolio Managers.

**Board Succession**

The Board comprises six Directors. There were some changes during the 2023 calendar
year, as we welcomed Julia Goh on 1st January 2023, and said goodbye to Harry Morley,
who retired from the Board in May 2023.

The Board can confirm that its current composition is compliant with all applicable
diversity targets for UK companies listed on the premium segment of the London Stock
Exchange. It is the Board’s intention that this will continue to be the case.

**The Manager**

The Board, through its Management Engagement Committee, monitors the performance
of the Manager, JPMorgan Funds Limited (‘JPMF’) on an ongoing basis. It is the Board’s
opinion that the Manager’s performance remains strong. Based upon this, having taken
all factors into account, including other services provided to the Company and its
shareholders, the Board is satisfied that JPMF should continue as the Company’s 
Manager and that its ongoing appointment remains in the best interests of shareholders.

**Annual General Meeting**

The Company’s one hundred and thirty eighth Annual General Meeting will be held 
at Trinity House, Tower Hill, London EC3N 4DH on Wednesday 29th May 2024 at 12.00
noon. In addition to the formal part of the meeting, there will be a presentation
from the Portfolio Managers who will answer questions on the portfolio and performance.
The meeting will be followed by a buffet lunch which will give shareholders an opportunity
to meet the Board, the Portfolio Managers and representatives of the Manager.

**Outlook**

Interest rates are expected to begin falling sometime soon, and leading indicators
are pointing to some strengthening in activity, so corporate earnings are also likely
to improve over the coming year. These developments should add momentum to the recent
upturn in market sentiment. The Board therefore shares the Portfolio Managers’ confidence
in the prospects for mid and smaller cap stocks during 2024 and beyond.

The Company’s prospects are equally bright in our view. Existing portfolio holdings
have been performing well despite the challenging conditions of the past year and
should do even better as and when the economy strengthens. In addition, the current
very attractive valuations mean new investment opportunities among mid and smaller
cap stocks are numerous, and the Portfolio Managers’ track record attests to their
ability to identify and capitalise on the most compelling of these opportunities.
All this suggests that the scene is set for the Company to deliver further capital
and dividend growth to shareholders as we head into the future. 

We thank you for your ongoing support.

**Angus Gordon Lennox**

Chairman                                                                        

11th April 2024

**PORTFOLIO MANAGERS’ REPORT**

**Setting the scene: inflation and central banks**

This has been a rather testing year for the UK market, with the direction of travel
being driven to a major extent by the path of inflation, the actions of the Bank
of England, and the impact of these upon expectations of future economic growth.

With high inflation and rapid, if belated, tightening of monetary policy, a deep
and painful domestic recession was widely predicted. Confounding this almost uniformly
negative sentiment, the economy continued to demonstrate more resilience than feared,
leading the market to oscillate between bouts of optimism and then pessimism, although
overall languishing for most of the year as we waited for the inevitable to bite.

While inflation in the UK had proven to be stickier than in most countries, some
of this was simply mechanical due to time lags, and it began to moderate more substantially
towards the end of 2023. This, combined with weakening economic indicators, gave
the market a glimpse that perhaps the monetary tightening cycle could be nearing
a turn, which then drove a sharp rally in UK assets through November and December.
Despite this double-digit final quarter, for the year as a whole our target market
of UK medium and smaller companies (the ‘Benchmark’) only managed a small positive
return, of +1.8%.

**Mercantile performance**

Against this somewhat uninspiring backdrop, for the year to 31st January 2024 the
Company delivered a return on net assets of +4.5% with debt valued at par, and +
5.4% with debt at fair value, in both cases ahead of the Benchmark’s +1.8% return.
This outperformance was driven by stock selection. Gearing, which averaged 12% over
the year, was additive to performance on a gross basis but not quite enough to offset
its costs, which are thankfully fixed in nature. This recent performance extends
the Company’s track record of outperformance over the long-term: in the ten years
to end January 2024, its NAV delivered an annualised total return of +6.1% with 
debt valued at par, and +6.6% with debt at fair value, again both ahead of the benchmark
annualised return of +4.5%.

**Performance attribution**

For the year ended 31st January 2024

Performance attribution analyses how the Company achieved its recorded performance
relative to its benchmark index.

| ** ** | **%** | **%** | 
| **Contributions to total return** | ** ** | ** ** | 
| **Benchmark total return** | ** ** | **1.8%** | 
|   Allocation/Stock/Sector Effect | 3.2% |  | 
|   Effect of Cash & Gearing | 0.5% |  | 
|   Cost of Debentures and Senior Unsecured Privately Placed Loan Notes | -0.6% |  | 
| **Portfolio Total Return** | ** ** | **4.9%** | 
|   Management Fees/Other Expenses |  | -0.5% | 
|   Share Buy-Back/Issuance |  | 0.1% | 
| **Cum Par Net Asset Value Total Return^(APM)** | ** ** | **4.5%** | 
|   Impact of Debt Valuation |  | 0.9% | 
| **Cum Fair Net Asset Value Total Return^(APM)** | ** ** | **5.4%** |

APM Alternative Performance Measure (‘APM’).

Source: JPMAM and Morningstar. All figures are on a total return basis.

Contributions calculated using an Arithmetic methodology.

**A glossary of terms and APMs is provided in the 2024 Annual Report.**

**Spotlight on stocks**

**Winners**

Performance this year was aided by a strong outturn from several of our longer-standing
investments, led by our substantial holdings in the investment banking and brokerage
services sector. Private equity group **3i** continued to deliver better than expected
sales growth thanks to Action, a retailer that now accounts for close to two thirds
of its net assets, while the fund-raising and financial performance of **Intermediate
Capital**, an alternative asset manager, remained strong despite a well-reported
industry-wide softening in demand for such strategies.

Other portfolio highlights this year included our significant holdings in the software
and computer services sector, in companies such as **Bytes Technology**, **Softcat**
and **Computacenter**, which have benefitted from robust corporate demand for IT
infrastructure. These companies have also seen gains in market share and there is
scope for revenue to accelerate further as customers begin to adopt generative AI
solutions.

Given the overwhelmingly bearish views of the prospects for the domestic economy,
it was particularly pleasing to see a strong contribution to returns from our holdings
in the household goods and home construction sector, led by our longstanding investment
in **Bellway** but also from **Redrow**. The market had been quick to mark down 
these shares aggressively given their high economic sensitivity, but valuations 
had reached extreme levels, hence we increased our holdings materially, which was
then well rewarded once the shares repriced more favourably as the probability of
the most negative scenarios diminished through the year.

**Losers**

It is inevitable that not all our investments will be winners, and while this is
a fact of life, it does not diminish from the frustration at times. Our holding 
in **Watches of Switzerland**, a luxury watch retailer, was our largest detractor
this year by some margin. We had reduced our position size somewhat on the back 
of a moderating growth profile, but a move by their key supplier Rolex into retail,
via the succession-driven acquisition of Bucherer, exacerbated market concerns. 
This was then compounded by a material profit warning, following weaker than expected
trading over the Christmas period. While this is the first profit warning that the
company has issued since its listing in 2019, it raises significant questions over
the deliverability of their long-range growth targets, so we have exited the investment
in full, preferring to reallocate the capital elsewhere while continuing to monitor
their progress.

Our investment in **Future**, the specialist media platform, also came under pressure
as audience figures and thus revenue – particularly in their important consumer 
technology products offering – declined, leading to a reduction in expected earnings.
In addition, fears around the potential impact of AI and third-party cookies changes,
combined with a management transition, placed further downward pressure on the company’s
share price. However, with the shares at an extreme valuation, which we do not believe
gives fair credit to their Go-Compare price comparison website business, we remain
shareholders, and with the new CEO now in place, we are monitoring progress closely.

**Positioning the portfolio for future success**

We target UK companies outside of the [FTSE 100](https://www.directorstalkinterviews.com/news/ftse-100)
Index that have significant opportunities for growth and which may be overlooked
by other investors. We invest in the shares of companies that we believe possess
the characteristics that may facilitate this growth, for example nimble business
models that can innovate or disrupt their industries, or companies that occupy prime
positions in rapidly growing markets.

Through the course of any individual year there are adjustments to the portfolio
to reflect the changing environment, as investment hypotheses run their course or
are proved invalid, or as share price moves present better opportunities elsewhere.
Over the past few years there have been multiple turning points for markets as well
as numerous changes to the operating environments of our portfolio companies. Despite
this, portfolio turnover has remained somewhat lower than long-term averages, reflecting
what we believe to be a resiliently positioned portfolio and our clear focus on 
the long-term prospects of holdings.

Furthermore, we have been operating in a volatile environment, with a pandemic and
associated restrictions, supply chain challenges, surging then falling inflation,
a drastic shift in monetary policy, war in Europe and the Middle East and an evident
souring of East-West relations. We believe that this backdrop has made it even more
important to focus on well-positioned and well-managed businesses that have the 
resilience to cope and even thrive in a variety of situations, and which may ultimately
emerge with stronger competitive positions.

Over the last year there have been various changes to the portfolio’s constituents
and thus its overall shape, and while some of these are reasonably material, it 
should also be read in the context of a portfolio in which over 80% remains unaltered.
While these changes are all based on single stock investment or divestment decisions,
from a top-down perspective these could be summarised by stating that the portfolio
today has an increased exposure to domestic compared to international end markets
versus one year ago, with even more technology-related holdings, and with an increased
amount of capital invested in the housebuilders and in real estate more broadly.

In the software and computer services sector, we added to our investment in **Bytes
Technology**, the aforementioned value-added technology reseller. We also made a
new investment in **Moneysupermarket.com**, a price comparison business seeing increased
demand due to higher insurance prices and where, now that their technology re-platforming
is complete, there is scope to improve profitability by increasing direct-to-site
traffic and cross-sell in place of pay-per-click.

As already explained above, we made additions to our housebuilding positions through
the year, adding to the pre-existing positions in **Bellway** and **Redrow**, while
also adding a new investment in **Vistry**.

Having previously had a very bearish view on the outlook for real estate more broadly,
this has become more nuanced over the year, as many of the negative factors that
we anticipated have played out and driven share price falls: valuations came under
downward pressure through an environment of rapid increases to interest rates and
thus the discount rates upon which property valuations are based. While we still
maintain a significant overall underweight in this sector relative to the benchmark,
we have moderated its size, and last year we started our initial foray back into
this space, taking positions in some of the most attractive propositions, with investments
in **LondonMetric Property**, **Shaftesbury Capital** and **Tritax Big Box REIT**,
each of which we believe to be exposed to end markets that will deliver robust rental
growth in coming years.

Other stock specific changes include a large increase in the size of our position
in **Hill & Smith**, an infrastructure engineer. This comes in response to the company’s
improving growth opportunity, driven primarily by an expansion of US infrastructure
spending. We also made a new investment in **Bodycote**, an industrial engineer 
which should benefit from the continued post-pandemic recovery of the aerospace 
industry, and in **Jet2**, the airline and package holiday provider, which has benefitted
from robust consumer demand, and which continues to generate market share gains.

These purchases were funded by various sales, including the previously mentioned**
Watches of Switzerland**, a substantial reduction in the size of our position in**
RS Group**, a distributor of electronics and industrial products, and exits from**
Pets At Home**, a pet product retailer and services provider, and from **Spirax-
Sarco**, our longstanding investment in a supplier of specialist industrial machinery,
now a FTSE 100 company.

**Outlook for the coming year**

Financial markets continue to be heavily influenced by the inter-connected forces
of inflation, monetary policy, and the impact of these upon economic growth expectations.
While the domestic economy through the end of last year was undoubtedly lacklustre,
and the UK may have experienced a recession, evidence thus far would suggest that
this is more likely behind than ahead of us, and if so, it will have proven to have
been far briefer and shallower than most were anticipating. Indeed, employment levels
have remained resilient and following 13 consecutive months of real wage declines,
the average consumer has now experienced over ten months of real wage growth. Coincident
with this, consumer and business confidence indicators are pointing to an improving
picture, which could lay the foundations for greater consumer demand, more business
investment, and thus lead to a better environment for corporate earnings growth.

Any improvement in such prospects could yield healthy market gains, as the prevailing
negative sentiment and uncertainty over the outlook is evidently reflected in valuations,
with the UK market trading at a steep discount to both its own history and relative
to other developed markets. Within the UK, given their greater economic cyclicality
and sensitivity to interest rates, mid-and small-caps are trading at a discount 
relative to their usual level versus large caps. Furthermore, portfolio companies
have, for the most part, been performing well at an operational level, as demonstrated
by a gradual, but notable, increase in earnings estimates over the year. Notwithstanding
the obvious geopolitical risks that surround us, or those associated with around
half of the world’s population – including the UK – voting in elections in the coming
year, we are excited by the investment opportunities that this combination of low
valuations, improving economic indicators, and strong performing portfolio companies
yields. This backdrop explains our elevated level of gearing, which at the date 
of this report is approximately 15%. This is the highest level of gearing that we
have applied in over a decade, which hopefully demonstrates most clearly our assessment
of the opportunity before us.

We will maintain our focus on investing in structurally robust businesses that operate
in growing end markets and possess the ability to invest capital at attractive returns
and which can also adapt to the changing environments in which they operate. We 
believe that a portfolio of such investments offers the best prospect of delivering
compelling returns and outperformance for our shareholders over the long-term, just
as they have done in the past.

**Guy Anderson**

**Anthony Lynch**

Portfolio Managers, Mercantile Investment Trust 

11th April 2024

Share on:
