# Fidelity European Values PLC A difficult year for equities

- Link: https://www.directorstalkinterviews.com/fidelity-european-values-plc-a-difficult-year-for-equities/412769756
- Published: 2019-03-15T07:25:39+00:00
- Author: Giles Arbor

**Fidelity European Values PLC** ([LON:FEV](https://www.directorstalkinterviews.com/company/fidelity-european-trust/fev.l))
today provided final results for the year ended 31st December 2018.

**Financial Highlights:**

 * Fidelity European Values PLC recorded a net asset value (“NAV) per share total
   return of -4.8% for the year ended 31 December 2018, while the Benchmark Index,
   the FTSE World Europe (ex UK) Index, returned -9.5%.
 * The discount widened from 8.6% to 10.7%, as a result of the share price total
   return of -6.8%.
 * The Board recommends a final dividend of 6.28 pence per share for approval by
   shareholders at the AGM on 13 May 2019. In addition, the Board has decided from
   the 2019 financial year to pay both an interim and a final dividend.
 * In a difficult year for equities, the Portfolio Manager’s strong stock selection
   capabilities were once again the significant drivers of performance with several
   high-conviction holdings contributing positively to returns.

**Chairman’s Statement**

Fidelity European Values PLC aims to be the cornerstone long term investment of 
choice for those seeking European exposure across market cycles.

The Portfolio Manager, Sam Morse’s, approach in managing the Company’s portfolio
is to look beyond the economic and political noise and concentrate on the real-life
progress of listed businesses across this large and diverse region. In running the
portfolio, he focuses on researching and investing in stocks he believes can grow
their dividends consistently, irrespective of the prevailing backdrop. Companies
with the cushion of a healthy and growing dividend also tend to be resilient during
periods of macroeconomic uncertainty. By investing in solid and sustainable dividend-
paying companies, Sam believes that the Company provides core defensive exposure
to European equities with the potential to outperform indices over the long term.

**Performance**
 The Company recorded a net asset value (“NAV”) per share total 
return of -4.8% for the year ended 31 December 2018, while the Benchmark Index, 
the FTSE World Europe (ex UK) Index, returned -9.5%. The share price total return
over this period was -6.8%. In a difficult year for equities, Sam’s strong stock
selection capabilities were once again the significant drivers of performance with
several of our high-conviction holdings contributing positively to returns. In addition,
the Company’s NAV total return performance over three and five years remains ahead
of the Benchmark.

Investor sentiment took a turn for the worse last year, particularly in the second
half, as markets faced twin headwinds of trade tensions and rising interest rates.
The market movements in Europe were in line with larger global trends in general,
but the environment was further aggravated by the chronic government budget deficit
in Italy and political unrest in Spain, while the possibility of a disorderly Brexit
and its implication for the European economy remains a concern. As the Company is
a UK business with predominantly UK investors and no overseas suppliers, the Board’s
focus is on the impact of market and investment risk. At the time that this statement
was written, it was still not clear whether the Prime Minister’s proposed Brexit
agreement would eventually be ratified by Parliament, whether there might be an 
exit without any form of agreement or whether Brexit might be delayed by way of 
an extension to Article 50, which governs secession by individual states. How markets
will react depends largely on what they have already discounted, and in the Portfolio
Manager’s Review, Sam gives a more detailed view on which European sectors and stocks
held in the portfolio might prove vulnerable in those circumstances. The outlook
in this respect is still finely balanced. This is why Sam looks beyond these shorter
term uncertainties and positions the portfolio for the longer term, by which time
Brexit will be history, for better or worse.

These factors coupled with rising borrowing costs owing to normalisation of monetary
policy by various central banks, most notably in the US, resulted in a sharp sell-
off towards the end of the year. It was also a contrast to the relative calm which
had prevailed over the last few years. Underlying the market movements was an increased
number of earnings downgrades given slowing global growth. Europe has many of the
world’s biggest exporters and the economy is particularly exposed to global trade.
This also resulted in a significant de-rating of equities in Europe.

**Outlook**
 Lead indicators for the global economy have slowed, prompting investors
to become more cautious. While the region’s economic expansion is expected to be
supported by favourable domestic demand, the pace of expansion is likely to be moderate.
Equity markets are set to face some challenges due to ongoing trade concerns between
the US and its trading partners. Concerns around the fiscal challenges in Italy,
continuing uncertainty over Brexit and the current slowdown in global economic growth,
may negatively impact investors’ preference for risk assets. Nonetheless, an uncertain
market environment is likely to create buying opportunities for long term investors,
and in these circumstances your Portfolio Manager’s concentration on fundamentally
strong businesses should continue to help performance.

**OTHER MATTERS**
 **Management Fees** With a view to reducing costs for our shareholders,
the Board agreed a new tiered fee structure which was effective on 1 April 2018.
The previous fee of 0.85 per cent per annum only applies to the first £400 million
of the Company’s net assets and a lower rate of 0.75 per cent per annum applies 
to net assets in excess of £400 million. Given the value of shareholders’ funds 
of £955.3m as at 31 December 2018, this represents an important saving for shareholders.

**Allocation of Fees and Finance Costs**
 As mentioned in last year’s Annual Report,
and effective from 1 January 2018, 75% of the Company’s management fees and finance
costs are now charged to capital and 25% to revenue. This better reflects the balance
of the capital and revenue elements of total return experienced historically over
the longer term. Previously, these costs were charged in their entirety to revenue.
The change does not affect the total return although relative rates of taxation 
of income and capital gains may be a consideration for some investors. As a result
of this change, the revenue return for this reporting year is higher than in prior
years and this is reflected in the final dividend proposed.

**Dividends**
 The Board recommends a final dividend of 6.28 pence per share for
the year ended 31 December 2018 for approval by shareholders at the AGM on 13 May
2019. The dividend will be payable on 17 May 2019 to those shareholders who appear
on the share register at close of business on 29 March 2019 (the ex-dividend date
will be 28 March 2019). 1.79 pence per share of the recommended dividend represents
the increased revenue generated from the change in the allocation of the management
fees and finance costs as mentioned above. If this element is excluded, the underlying
4.49 pence represents an increase of 3.2 per cent year on year.

While the Board has not sought to influence the Portfolio Manager by imposing any
income objective in any particular year – and this remains the case – the investment
focus on companies capable of growing their dividend has seen the Company’s dividend
payments rise over time. Because the Board acknowledges that both capital and income
growth are components of performance, as reflected in the change of investment objective
approved by shareholders at the Annual General Meeting last year, it considers that
this is an appropriate time to move to a more clearly defined progressive dividend
practice.

The aim therefore will be to increase the dividend each year. The exceptional circumstances
in which this might not prove possible include, first, if sterling were to rise 
substantially against the euro; secondly, if economic trends prove to be unusually
adverse; and thirdly, if the Portfolio Manager shifts the emphasis of companies 
held to ones with a materially lower overall yield than hitherto.

In order to help realise its aim, the Board has decided gradually to augment revenue
reserves by retaining a minor proportion of earnings from year to year. By law this
proportion is not permitted to exceed 15 per cent. By way of example, for the 2018
financial year the dividend of 6.28 pence is being paid from earnings of 6.94 pence
per share, a retention rate of about 9 per cent. The Board expects that as revenue
reserves build up, they will assist, if necessary, in smoothing dividend growth 
year on year, in the event of the sorts of exceptional circumstances outlined above.

Finally, as the Company has a significant retail shareholder base and in order to
smooth the dividend payments throughout the year, the Board has decided from the
2019 financial year to pay both an interim and a final dividend, which it is hoped
will be welcomed by shareholders. It is expected that in normal circumstances the
interim dividend will represent somewhat under half the total dividend for the financial
year, and will be paid in November 2019, following the interim results.

**Discount Management and Treasury Shares**
 The Board operates an active discount
management policy, the primary purpose of which is to reduce discount volatility.
As of this year, the Board is seeking to maintain the discount in single digits 
in normal market conditions. Buying shares at a discount also results in an enhancement
to the NAV per share. The Board has shareholder approval to hold in Treasury shares
repurchased by the Company, rather than cancelling them, and these shares are then
available to be sold at a premium to NAV, facilitating the management of, and potentially
enhancing, liquidity in the Company’s shares. The Board is seeking shareholder approval
to renew this authority at the forthcoming AGM.

As a result of the widening of the discount during the year, the Company repurchased
3,029,351 ordinary shares into Treasury. Since the beginning of the year and as 
at the date of this report, the Company has not repurchased any further ordinary
shares.

**Gearing**
 The Company continues to gear through the use of derivative instruments,
primarily contracts for difference (“CFDs”), and the Manager has flexibility to 
gear within the parameters set by the Board. As at 31 December 2018, the Company’s
gross gearing was 10.1% (2017: 13.2%) whilst net gearing was 6.1% (2017: 3.6%). 
In the reporting year, gearing made a small negative contribution to performance,
as can be seen from the attribution analysis table in the Annual Report.

The Board monitors the level of gearing and the use of derivative instruments carefully
and has defined a risk control framework for this purpose which is reviewed at each
Board meeting.

**Board of Directors**
 After serving on the Board for over ten years as a non-executive
Director and nearly eight years as Senior Independent Director and Chairman of the
Audit Committee, James Robinson stepped down from the Board at the conclusion of
the AGM on 14 May 2018. At the same time, James was succeeded as Audit Committee
Chair by Fleur Meijs and as Senior Independent Director by Marion Sears.

We continue to review Board composition and Directors’ succession on a regular basis
to ensure that we have a Board with a mix of tenures and one which provides diversity
of perspective together with the range of appropriate skills and experience for 
your Company. In accordance with the UK Corporate Governance Code, and being a FTSE
350 Company, all Directors are subject to annual re-election by shareholders and
put themselves forward for re-election at the forthcoming AGM. Biographical details
of each Director are shown in the Annual Report.

**Annual General Meeting**
 The AGM of the Company will be held at midday on Monday
13 May 2019 at Fidelity’s offices at25 Cannon Street, London EC4M 5TA (nearest tube
stations are St Paul’s and Mansion House). Full details of the meeting are given
in the Annual Report.

This is our opportunity to meet as many shareholders as possible, and I hope therefore
that you are able to join us. In addition to the formal business of the meeting,
Sam Morse, your Portfolio Manager, will be making a presentation on the year’s results
and the outlook for 2019.

Vivian Bazalgette
 Chairman 14 March 2019

**Portfolio Manager’s Review**

Sam Morse was appointed as Portfolio Manager of Fidelity European Values PLC on 
1 January 2011. He has also managed the Fidelity European Fund since 1 January 2010.
He first joined Fidelity as a research analyst and covered a range of sectors before
becoming an equity income fund manager. He also worked as Head of Equities at M&
G.

**Question**

How has the Company performed in the year under review?

**Answer**

The Company had a disappointing year in absolute terms with the NAV total return
falling by 4.8% and the share price total return falling by 6.8% as the discount
widened. I hope it will be some consolation to shareholders that the Company’s NAV
and share price both fell less than the Benchmark Index which was down by 9.5%.

**Question**

And what has the market environment been like in the year under review?

**Answer**

2018 was a year of growing uncertainty, which is never good for stock market returns.
As in a suspense movie, investors spent much of the year fearing what might come
next. When the year began, the global economy was humming, earnings estimates were
rising and there appeared to be few clouds on the horizon. Within a few weeks, however,
and just as the ink dried on endless optimistic projections by strategy teams around
the City, the angst began. Investors started to worry: ‘is this as good as it gets’?
Then as the year progressed, ‘events’ provided more reasons to fear what might come
next. We ended the year almost at the other end of the spectrum: fearing the impact
of trade wars, higher interest rates in the US, the unpredictability of populist
political agendas, etc., and all this just as the European Central Bank (“ECB”) 
finally ended its programme of quantitative easing! December saw a dramatic sell-
off and what was touted, at the outset, to be a banner year for stock market investors,
turned into a very disappointing year with only cash providing a positive return.

**Question**

What have been the key contributors to performance? And detractors?

**Answer**

The focus on reliable dividend growers often means that the Company holds up relatively
well when investors grow more nervous and when equity markets struggle and this 
was the case in 2018. Other factors contributed positively too, such as sector positioning,
e.g. being overweight in technology and underweight in automobiles, and the focus
on strong balance sheets as investors became increasingly concerned about financial
leverage. Stock-picking, however was, as usual, the main determinant of relative
performance. The financial sector provided the greatest boost, in aggregate, to 
relative performance. Deutsche Boerse was a strong individual contributor, as detailed
in the interim report, but more generally, avoiding low-return banks, seen early
in the year as recovery plays on the back of rising interest rates, helped when 
it turned out that interest rates in Europe were, as the President of the ECB Mario
Draghi confirmed, going nowhere until at least after the summer of 2019. The top
individual contributor for the year was Edenred – the global leader in managing 
employee benefit programs for corporates (remember luncheon vouchers?) – which saw
an acceleration in organic and inorganic growth under the stewardship of a relatively
new management team. Brazil is the single biggest area for Edenred so optimism about
the prospects for that country, following the election of Bolsonaro, gave the stock
an extra lift too. As always, there were also disappointments in terms of stock 
picking. The most notable of these was Iliad Group, the French telecoms company,
which suffered from poor execution in an increasingly competitive market and Atlantia,
the Italian motorways operator, which had a major setback when the Morandi bridge
collapsed with tragic consequences.

**Question**

There have been a number of challenges for European equity managers this year, not
least the high sales exposure to emerging markets of many European companies, rising
input prices and political uncertainty. How have you navigated these?

**Answer**

More than a quarter of sales by European companies are now made in emerging markets
which demonstrates their considerable success in expanding outside their domestic
markets. Emerging markets may be unfashionable today, having had a difficult 2018,
but the longer term growth prospects remain good. My investment approach is to try
to make sure that we own the best balance of companies with respect to consistent
dividend growth and what is discounted in the share’s valuation. I tend not to react
to events or changes in stock market fashions but try to make sure that there is
a balance in the portfolio across sectors and regions, including emerging markets,
which will make sure that the Company can perform consistently in different environments.
Rising input prices are a function of where we are in the economic cycle. If a company
has pricing power, it is often able to pass these rising input prices on to customers
and mitigate any hit to margins. Weaker businesses will struggle to do so. I have
always favoured companies with strong pricing power which are often strong business
franchises that are capable of growing their dividends consistently. Political uncertainty
is, I’m afraid, here to stay. Ultimately, strong businesses which can deliver consistent
dividend growth will continue to thrive in difficult times even though political
uncertainty may cause the markets to be volatile on a shorter term view.

**Question**

What have been the major changes to the portfolio over the period?

**Answer**

I seldom make ‘major’ changes to the portfolio because my investment horizon is 
quite long term. I am focused on attractively-valued companies, which I think can
grow their dividends consistently on a three to five year view. Indeed, many of 
the Company’s investments have been held throughout my tenure as this Company’s 
Portfolio Manager, which is now more than eight years. As a result, the turnover
in the portfolio tends to be quite low and 2018 was no exception to this. Holdings
in BIC Group, the lighters to pens company, Elior, the contract caterer, Anheuser-
Busch InBev, the beer company, and Aena, the Spanish airports owner and operator,
were all sold during the year. The first three were sold on concerns regarding their
dividend outlook given deteriorating fundamentals while Aena, which has been a very
rewarding investment since purchase around three years ago, was sold because the
valuation was no longer as attractive. I was concerned that the strategy of the 
company might change for the worse following the election of a new government in
Spain. One new holding was added during the year: Grifols, which is one of the global
leaders in plasma-derived treatments, where we expect to see earnings growth accelerate
beyond expectations as the number of suitable indications grow and as newly-opened
collection centres mature.

**Question**

How has your derivative strategy performed in the year under review?

**Answer**

Gearing did not help given falling markets and unfortunately, the short portfolio
did not really add much value either. Having said that, there have been some soft
benefits in terms of meeting companies and analysts with whom I might not formerly
have engaged. Assessing performance over one year is also, probably, too short a
period to draw a conclusion as to the merits of this shorting strategy. However,
I am mindful that time focused on the derivatives strategy may distract from or 
dilute the main objectives of the Company. I have committed to the Board that, until
there is evidence that this strategy works, I will not make it a larger proportion
of the Company. Time will tell.

**Question**

The market seems to be assuming that there will, ultimately, be an agreed withdrawal
deal between the UK and the EU. What if there isn’t? How would that impact the Trust?

**Answer**

The UK represents a small proportion of continental European companies’ sales and
profits: less than 5%. So the direct consequences of a ‘no deal’ Brexit, and a subsequent
devaluation of UK sterling, would be minimal for most companies. Those more affected
would be companies with larger businesses in the UK such as the Spanish banks Santander
and Sabadell. A number of companies, such as those in the auto sector, might also
suffer from short term disruption due to supply chain issues if there is a ‘no deal’
Brexit. A devaluation of UK sterling in the event of a ‘no deal’ Brexit would, however,
result in exchange rate gains for UK sterling investors in the Company. An appreciation
of UK sterling would have an opposite effect. Note 17 in the Financial Statements
below provides foreign currency risk sensitivity analysis. There may, of course,
also be some indirect consequences, or second order effects, such as a general drop
in business confidence which may affect equities negatively.

**Question**

What should investors remain focused on in the months ahead?

**Answer**

Focus on the long term. The Russians, I am told, have a proverb that says: ‘if your
shoes are dirty, point to the horizon’. Well the shoes may be a little dirty as 
we enter 2019 which could be a tricky year for European stock markets given on-going
earnings downgrades, Brexit machinations, continued uncertainty about the impact
of US Federal Reserve tightening and the end of quantitative easing in Europe. In
the long term it pays to stay invested in equities and, in particular, in those 
companies that are able to grow their dividends consistently. Valuation is improving
but we are far from trough levels. The current dividend yield of the European markets
is only about 70% of the highest level seen during my tenure as Portfolio Manager
of the Company. Often, in a fundamental downturn, valuations become very cheap in
historical terms. Fidelity has pointed out many times, however, that it is extremely
difficult to try and time markets, so my policy is to stay fully invested and ride
through the cyclical ups and downs of the market. In the long term, investors are
rewarded for taking that risk. For my part, I will continue to focus on attractively
valued cash-generative companies, with strong balance sheets, which have the potential
to grow their dividends consistently over the next three to five years.

Sam Morse
 Fidelity European Values PLC Portfolio Manager 14 March 2019

Share on:
